Challenging the secret
“Israel Nuclear Weapons Gag Order” WNP-136

by | Jul 14, 2022

UPDATED: December 17, 2019


IRmep has filed a 39-page federal lawsuit (PDF) challenging the secrecy of a gag order—WNP-136 (PDF)—that forbids all U.S. government agency employees and contractors from discussing Israel’s nuclear weapons program.

“Nuclear weapons did not deter Egypt and Syria from attacking Israel in 1973, Argentina from attacking British territory in the 1982 Falklands War or Iraq from attacking Israel during the 1991 Gulf War.”

After an unknown congressional staffer read the article and demanded a review, it was referred to classification officials for a second review. Doyle’s pay was then cut, his home computer searched, and he was fired.

IRmep alleges in the lawsuit that the American public has been harmed by being kept in the dark about U.S. policy toward the Israeli nuclear weapons program. Important questions include:

  1. Should Israel’s nuclear weapons facilities be inspected by the International Atomic Energy Agency?
  2. Where does Israel dispose of the toxic waste its program generates?
  3. Is the U.S. still vigorously investigating (though not prosecuting) diversions of materials and technologies to Israel, as it did in the past over nuclear triggers (The Milchan-Netanyahu krytron smuggling ring), weapons grade uranium (NUMEC), oscilloscopes and other weapons development technology diversions (Telogy LLC)?
  4. Are Israel’s nuclear weapons used to coerce the U.S. into making adverse policy decisions?
  5. Besides apartheid South Africa, has Israel offered any of its nuclear weapons for sale to other foreign countries?
  6. Has Israel mounted nuclear weapons onto its German-supplied Dolphin-class submarines?

As documented in the lawsuit, WNP-136 is not really a classification guidance, but rather a legislative rule designed to prevent covered parties from commenting on information already in the public domain, while prohibiting the release of additional information about Israel’s nuclear weapons program held by various government agencies. IRmep submits as evidence transcripts of reporter Sam Husseini’s video documentaries of questions posed to executive agency and White House officials, as well as U.S. Department of State John Kirby’s refusal to answer questions about former Secretary of State Colin Powell’s statement that “Israel had over 200 nuclear weapons pointed at Tehran.”

468